« Atlanta Weather | Main | Redux: The Non-Taxpaying Class »
بدھ 4 دسمبر 2002Wednesday, December 04, 2002
History of Abrahamic Religions
I am interested in finding out more about the history of Judaism, Christianity and Islam. Not from the point of view of their followers, but from good scholarly sources which discuss independent sources for the history of the early periods of these religions as well as the history of the Bible and the Quran (based on analysis of their text as well as the history of their compilation etc.) I would like to know what events in the Bible we can confirm independently, for example. I understand that we cannot independently say anything one way or the other about quite a few of the events in the Bible as well as early Muslim history.
A couple of articles related to the Quran were in the NY Times and the Atlantic some time ago. However, one of the biggest problems I have found when searching for material on this topic is that of the author’s bias. There are usually two kinds of people writing in this area: those whose aim is to refute the religion (for example, here), and those who want to defend it (an example is here). Usually, both these groups make outrageous claims. As someone who believes in one’s religion but is not overly religious, I find both approaches highly problematic and not intellectually honest.
I suppose doing research and writing on Islam in this context has also become very difficult in recent years due to the profileration of fatwas for blasphemy that got started with Salman Rushdie. It probably is much easier to write about the history of Judaism and Christianity.
If anyone (Bill Allison, are you reading?) has any reading recommendations, please let me know.
Posted by Zack at December 4, 2002 4:25 PM in Islam and Other Religions
Advertisements
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.zackvision.com/mt/zv-trbk.cgi/224
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference History of Abrahamic Religions:
» Textual Analysis of Quran from Procrastination
Brian Ulrich points out an article in the Lebanon Daily Star about production of a critical edition of the Quran based on the manuscripts found in a Sanaa mosque in Yemen. A professor of literature and human science at Sousse... [Read More]
Tracked on December 2, 2005 3:57 PM
Comments
Posted by: Bill Allison (16 comments) at December 8, 2002 12:48 PM
Thanks, Bill. The bias problem really is a major one in this area.
Posted by: Zack (1784 comments) at December 10, 2002 12:50 AM
Posted by: Mariam (8 comments) at January 19, 2006 7:00 PM
Mariam: Thanks. I have fixed the link to his website and added a link to Amazon for the book in your comment.
Posted by: Zack (1784 comments) at January 23, 2006 6:37 PM | PGP Sig
Post a comment
Note: Disagreements are welcome, but please keep it civil. Any comments full of hatred, bigotry, trolling or spam will be deleted and the commenter banned. Do read the commenting policy.
Valid XHTML: You have to preview your comment to make sure that it is valid XHTML 1.1. You will see the "Post" button on the preview page.
Urdu: To comment in Urdu, include "p[ur](urdu). " (with a space at the end and without the quotes) at the start of every Urdu paragraph. If you want to write an Urdu word(s) in an English paragraph, do it like this: %[ur](urdu)اردو%. If you want to put an English word(s) in an Urdu paragraph, write it like this: %[en](en)English words%.
PGP Signing: PGP-signed comments are encouraged. However, clearsigning Urdu text with GPGshell produces garbage.
MathML: Select the Textile with itex to MathML text filter. What you'll use is itex, which is a superset of WebTeX and differs somewhat from standard LaTeX.
Text Filters: For regular comments, whether in English or Urdu, keep the text filter setting to its default of Textile 2. Change it to Textile with itex to MathML when writing MathML.
I’ve started to respond on Ideofact
…but I’ll add more tomorrow. Short answers: Yes, I’m reading, but I probably don’t have too many good books to recommend…